OpEd

Harris v. Trump – Living (any of?) the Christian Principles?

What are “The Seven Deadly Sins”

The Seven Deadly Sins, also known as the Capital Vices, are a classification of vices in Christian teachings that are considered to be the root of other sins. These sins are often thought to lead to spiritual death if not confessed or repented. The seven deadly sins are:

  1. Pride: An inflated sense of one’s own status or accomplishments, often leading to arrogance and disdain for others.
  2. Greed: An excessive desire for material wealth or gain, at the expense of others or one’s ethics.
  3. Wrath: Extreme anger or hatred that leads to destructive actions, vengeance, or harm to others.
  4. Envy: Jealousy or a desire for what others possess, whether it’s their status, abilities, or possessions.
  5. Lust: An intense, uncontrollable desire, often for sexual pleasure, that can lead to immoral actions.
  6. Gluttony: Over-indulgence, especially related to food or drink, but also applicable to other forms of excess.
  7. Sloth: Laziness or the failure to act and use one’s abilities, particularly in matters of personal responsibility or spiritual growth.

These sins were popularized in medieval Christian doctrine and remain a common reference in literature, art, and religious teachings.

What are “The Ten Commandments”

The Ten Commandments are a set of ethical guidelines found in the Bible, given by God to Moses on Mount Sinai. They are foundational to both Jewish and Christian traditions. Below is a summary of the Ten Commandments as found in the book of Exodus 20:2–17 and Deuteronomy 5:6–21:

  1. You shall have no other gods before Me: Worship only God and no other deities.
  2. You shall not make for yourself an idol: Avoid the worship of idols or images.
  3. You shall not take the name of the Lord your God in vain: Use God’s name with reverence.
  4. Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy: Set aside the Sabbath (seventh) day for rest and worship.
  5. Honor your father and your mother: Show respect and care for your parents.
  6. You shall not murder: Respect the sanctity of life; do not kill.
  7. You shall not commit adultery: Maintain faithfulness in marriage.
  8. You shall not steal: Do not take what doesn’t belong to you.
  9. You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor: Avoid lying or giving false testimony.
  10. You shall not covet: Do not desire what belongs to others (their spouse, possessions, etc.).

These commandments serve as moral principles guiding behavior, relationships, and worship. They are referenced in both Jewish law and Christian teachings.

Evaluating Donald Trump in Terms of Christian Values

Evaluating a public figure like Donald Trump in terms of the Seven Deadly Sins and the Ten Commandments involves subjective interpretation and may vary depending on one’s personal or political perspective. I will provide a neutral summary of behaviors and actions that some critics and supporters may associate with these moral principles.

Trump v. Seven Deadly Sins

  1. Pride:
    • Supporters might view Trump’s confidence as strong leadership.
    • Critics often argue that Trump displays excessive pride or arrogance, particularly through his frequent boasting about personal achievements and downplaying of errors or failures.
  2. Greed:
    • Critics point to Trump’s business history, including bankruptcies and accusations of exploiting financial loopholes, as signs of greed.
    • Supporters could argue that Trump’s wealth demonstrates business acumen and success, not necessarily greed.
  3. Wrath:
    • Trump’s aggressive rhetoric, particularly on social media (e.g., Twitter), has been interpreted by some as a sign of wrath. His public feuds with political opponents and media outlets could be seen as retaliatory.
    • Others argue that his assertiveness reflects strength, not uncontrolled anger.
  4. Envy:
    • While there’s little direct evidence of envy, some have speculated that Trump’s frequent comparison with other political leaders (such as Barack Obama) could reflect this sin.
  5. Lust:
    • Trump has been involved in multiple scandals and lawsuits regarding sexual misconduct, which could be viewed as linked to lust.
    • Supporters may argue that these allegations are exaggerated or politically motivated.
  6. Gluttony:
    • There’s no significant evidence to suggest Trump indulges in gluttony in the traditional sense (i.e., overconsumption of food or drink).
  7. Sloth:
    • Some critics have accused Trump of spending significant time on leisure activities (such as golf), especially during his presidency.
    • Supporters counter that even while playing golf, Trump remained actively engaged in political affairs.

Trump v. The Ten Commandments

  1. You shall have no other gods before Me:
    • Some critics argue that Trump’s focus on wealth and power suggests a greater allegiance to these than to spiritual or ethical principles.
  2. You shall not make for yourself an idol:
    • Critics may suggest that Trump’s self-promotion or emphasis on personal branding borders on self-idolization.
  3. You shall not take the name of the Lord your God in vain:
    • There have been instances where Trump’s religious sincerity has been questioned, such as his use of religious symbols or rhetoric for political gain.
  4. Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy:
    • There’s little public focus on whether Trump personally observes the Sabbath, though he has made efforts to appeal to religious communities.
  5. Honor your father and your mother:
    • Trump has publicly spoken highly of his parents, particularly his father, Fred Trump, suggesting adherence to this commandment.
  6. You shall not murder:
    • There are no direct accusations here, but critics argue his rhetoric and policies (e.g., immigration or foreign relations) have indirectly led to harm.
  7. You shall not commit adultery:
    • Trump has admitted to infidelity in the past, which directly conflicts with this commandment. His multiple marriages and relationships have been scrutinized by critics.
  8. You shall not steal:
    • While not accused of theft in the traditional sense, Trump has faced legal scrutiny over financial practices and business dealings.
  9. You shall not bear false witness:
    • Critics frequently accuse Trump of lying or making false statements, particularly in public and political contexts.
  10. You shall not covet:
    • Some may argue that Trump’s focus on wealth, power, and stature reflects covetousness.

In summary, how one interprets Donald Trump’s actions in light of the Seven Deadly Sins and Ten Commandments depends largely on personal or political beliefs. Critics emphasize what they see as moral failings, while supporters often focus on his accomplishments and leadership qualities. Both views highlight the complexity of evaluating any public figure against these traditional moral standards.

___________________________________________________________________________

Evaluating Kamala Harris in Terms of Christian Values

Evaluating Kamala Harris in terms of the Seven Deadly Sins and the Ten Commandments involves a mix of subjective interpretation and public perception. Here’s a neutral assessment based on both criticisms and support for her actions and public life.

Is Harris warding off the Seven Deadly Sins?

  1. Pride:
    • Supporters view Harris’s self-assurance and confidence as essential traits for a leader, particularly as a trailblazer, being the first female, Black, and South Asian Vice President.
    • Critics sometimes perceive her demeanor and ambitious rise in politics as signs of pride or overconfidence. For example, her public responses in debates and interviews are sometimes seen as dismissive.
  2. Greed:
    • There’s no significant accusation of greed against Harris in a financial sense, although some critics argue that her political ambition could be seen as a desire for power and influence. Supporters might counter that ambition isn’t the same as greed and is necessary for political leadership.
  3. Wrath:
    • Wrath is not a significant criticism aimed at Harris. However, in heated Senate hearings or debates, her direct questioning style has sometimes been described as aggressive. Supporters argue that this reflects strength rather than anger.
  4. Envy:
    • There are no substantial accusations of envy in Harris’s public life. Her career has largely focused on self-advancement rather than comparisons with others, though some critics might perceive certain political attacks as rooted in jealousy of others’ success.
  5. Lust:
    • There are no prominent accusations or scandals involving lust linked to Harris, making this sin irrelevant in public discourse about her.
  6. Gluttony:
    • There’s no public evidence suggesting Harris has issues with gluttony, in terms of overindulgence in material goods, food, or drink.
  7. Sloth:
    • Harris is widely regarded as hardworking, especially given her rise through various political roles—district attorney, state attorney general, senator, and now vice president. Sloth has not been a criticism associated with her.

Is Harris Living by theTen Commandments?

  1. You shall have no other gods before Me:
    • There’s no indication that Harris has violated this commandment in terms of idolatry, though some religious critics may feel that her political positions (e.g., on abortion rights) conflict with their interpretations of religious principles.
  2. You shall not make for yourself an idol:
    • Harris has not been accused of creating idols, though her critics might argue that she places too much importance on political power. Supporters might argue she champions causes rather than self-promotion.
  3. You shall not take the name of the Lord your God in vain:
    • There are no public instances where Harris has been accused of using God’s name in vain or being irreverent toward religious values.
  4. Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy:
    • As a public figure, Harris does not openly discuss her observance of religious practices like the Sabbath, so it is difficult to assess her actions in relation to this commandment.
  5. Honor your father and your mother:
    • Harris has spoken fondly and respectfully of her parents, particularly her mother, whom she credits for much of her success. She appears to honor their memory publicly.
  6. You shall not murder:
    • While not personally involved in violence, Harris’s stance on issues such as abortion has led to criticism from religious conservatives who believe it conflicts with the spirit of this commandment. Supporters, on the other hand, argue that her stance supports reproductive rights and personal freedom.
  7. You shall not commit adultery:
    • There have been no accusations of adultery against Harris, and she is known for a stable marriage to her husband, Doug Emhoff.
  8. You shall not steal:
    • There are no allegations of theft or dishonesty involving Harris’s personal or professional life.
  9. You shall not bear false witness:
    • Critics have accused Harris of misrepresenting facts or shifting positions on key political issues, but her supporters argue that her positions have evolved based on changing contexts and public needs.
  10. You shall not covet:
    • There’s little evidence to suggest Harris has exhibited covetousness. Her critics tend to focus more on policy disagreements than on personal envy.

Summary

Supporters see Kamala Harris as a strong, hardworking leader who upholds many of the Ten Commandments and generally avoids the Seven Deadly Sins. Critics, on the other hand, focus on issues of pride and perceived ambition, and they may disagree with her political stances on moral grounds, such as her position on abortion.

Both interpretations depend on one’s political and moral perspective.

Evaluating Donald Trump in terms of the Fruits of the Holy Spirit

Evaluating Donald Trump in terms of the Fruits of the Holy Spirit is subjective, as it depends on one’s personal, political, and moral perspective. The Fruits of the Spirit, as listed in Galatians 5:22-23, are love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control. Here is an analysis based on Trump’s public behavior, speeches, and policies:

1. Love (Selfless concern for others):

  • Critics argue that Trump often displays divisiveness in his rhetoric, especially when dealing with political opponents, marginalized communities, or foreign adversaries. His speeches and social media activity are frequently seen as lacking empathy.
  • Supporters might highlight Trump’s policies that they believe promoted national security and economic growth, claiming he acted out of love for his country and its people.

2. Joy (Deep-seated happiness in God):

  • Critics note that Trump rarely conveys a sense of personal joy in his demeanor, often focusing on grievances, criticisms, and conflicts with opponents or the media.
  • Supporters may point to his moments of celebration, such as during rallies, where he seems to connect with his base with enthusiasm and a sense of joy in their shared goals.

3. Peace (Harmony and reconciliation):

  • Critics argue that Trump’s leadership style fostered division both within the United States and internationally. His administration was marked by ongoing tensions with political opponents, media outlets, and international figures.
  • Supporters might highlight Trump’s role in diplomatic breakthroughs, such as his efforts to negotiate with North Korea, or his work to broker the Abraham Accords between Israel and several Arab nations.

4. Patience (Endurance and perseverance):

  • Critics often claim that Trump lacks patience, citing his frequent public outbursts, particularly on social media, and quick dismissal of people who disagree with him.
  • Supporters argue that Trump demonstrated perseverance in his relentless pursuit of policy changes, particularly in the face of what they consider unfair opposition from political adversaries and the media.

5. Kindness (Gentleness and generosity to others):

  • Critics argue that Trump’s public persona and rhetoric lack kindness, especially toward those he views as adversaries. His language is often seen as harsh and confrontational.
  • Supporters may point to instances where Trump demonstrated kindness in more personal interactions, as well as to his administration’s policies that they believe benefitted specific communities, such as criminal justice reform efforts.

6. Goodness (Moral integrity):

  • Critics argue that Trump’s personal behavior, including his past scandals, financial dealings, and accusations of dishonesty, contradicts the Christian ideal of goodness.
  • Supporters might highlight policies they believe reflect goodness, such as pro-life stances, religious freedom protections, and efforts to strengthen the economy, which they believe improved the livelihoods of millions of Americans.

7. Faithfulness (Loyalty and trust in God and others):

  • Critics argue that Trump’s shifting political positions and treatment of former allies suggest a lack of faithfulness. His personal conduct, including infidelity, has also been a point of criticism.
  • Supporters point to his strong support of religious groups and faith-based initiatives, as well as his consistent stance on certain key issues, such as judicial appointments, which they see as evidence of his faithfulness to his promises.

8. Gentleness (Mildness of temper and humility):

  • Critics argue that Trump’s public demeanor, especially on social media, is often the opposite of gentleness, describing him as abrasive and confrontational.
  • Supporters may counter that Trump’s directness and assertiveness are necessary for leadership, viewing his approach as strength rather than a lack of gentleness.

9. Self-Control (Control over desires and impulses):

  • Critics highlight Trump’s frequent public outbursts, impulsive tweets, and his history of personal scandals as evidence of a lack of self-control.
  • Supporters may argue that, despite immense pressure from opposition, Trump demonstrated self-control in pursuing his policies and maintaining his political agenda despite ongoing criticism and investigations.

Conclusion:

Evaluating Donald Trump through the lens of the Fruits of the Holy Spirit is complex and highly influenced by individual perspectives. Critics tend to view his behavior as contrary to these virtues, while supporters might interpret his policies and leadership style as being rooted in concern for the country and its people. This evaluation depends greatly on one’s interpretation of his personal conduct, public policies, and overall leadership style.

[Analysis assisted with ChatGPT 4.0]